Shooter's Top 50

Guru Posts: 6117 Age: 21

This is who I believe to be the Top 50 players in the AFL.

This is only my opinion so you will all disagree with something so feel free to let me know if I have over-rated or under-rated anyone. If you feel I have left out someone who deserves to be in the list, then let me know.

All thoughts welcome.

1. Chris Judd (Carlton)
2. Lance Franklin (Hawthorn)
3. Gary Ablett Jr. (Geelong)
4. Nick Riewoldt (St. Kilda)
5. Dean Cox (West Coast)
6. Matthew Pavlich (Fremantle)
7. Luke Hodge (Hawthorn)
8. Matthew Scarlett (Geelong)
9. Adam Goodes (Sydney)
10. Jimmy Bartel (Geelong)
11. Chad Cornes (Port Adelaide)
12. Brent Harvey (North Melbourne)
13. Jonathan Brown (Brisbane)
14. Brendan Fevola (Carlton)
15. Adam Cooney (Western Bulldogs)
16. Sam Mitchell (Hawthorn)
17. Daniel Cross (Western Bulldogs)
18. Daniel Kerr (West Coast)
19. Matthew Richardson (Richmond)
20. Simon Black (Brisbane)
21. Joel Selwood (Geelong)
22. Joel Corey (Geelong)
23. Nathan Bock (Adelaide)
24. Cameron Ling (Geelong)
25. Brett Kirk (Sydney)
26. Sam Fisher (St. Kilda)
27. Brad Sewell (Hawthorn)
28. Ryan O'Keefe (Sydney)
29. Scott Thompson (Adelaide)
30. Dale Morris (Western Bulldogs)
31. Andrew McLeod (Adelaide)
32. Chance Bateman (Hawthorn)
33. Kane Cornes (Port Adelaide)
34. Luke Power (Brisbane)
35. Aaron Sandilands (Fremantle)
36. Ben Rutten (Adelaide)
37. Dane Swan (Collingwood)
38. Steve Johnson (Geelong)
39. Jarryd Roughead (Hawthorn)
40. Paul Medhurst (Collingwood)
41. Shaun Burgoyne (Port Adelaide)
42. Lindsay Gilbee (Western Bulldogs)
43. Travis Cloke (Collingwood)
44. Simon Goodwin (Adelaide)
45. Corey Enright (Geelong)
46. Brad Johnson (Western Bulldogs)
47. Robert Murphy (Western Bulldogs)
48. Nathan Foley (Richmond)
49. Daniel Motlop (Port Adelaide)
50. Brett Deledio (Richmond)

Legend Posts: 11569 Age: 20 Location: Adelaide

Pretty good list.

I still think that Chad is too high on the list, however

Administrator Posts: 10505 Location: Nth Queensland

Great list Shooter!

Cornes higher then Brown!?

J.Brown should be in the top ten in my opinion.

Legend Posts: 11984 Age: 17

Good list, but where is Kenelly?

Legend Posts: 12353 Age: 16 Location: Victoria

Hodge a bit high

JUDDY!!

Trav Cloke in there. hmm

Legend Posts: 12353 Age: 16 Location: Victoria

would you guys rather have Waite or Trav Cloke?

i think Waite better

Legend Posts: 10654 Age: 17 Location: Brisbane QLD

Good list.

Only things I dissagree with.

Goodes to high. >> 15th for me.
Cornes to high. >> 20th for me.
Bartel to low. >> Around 3ish for me.
Deledio to low. >> 45th for me.

Administrator Posts: 10505 Location: Nth Queensland

carlton09 wrote:

would you guys rather have Waite or Trav Cloke?

i think Waite better

Trav Cloke.

Guru Posts: 4881 Location: Melbourne

Good list
I don't want to get this started again, but I think Chad is about 10 places too high

Guru Posts: 6117 Age: 21

TheFeldster wrote:

Pretty good list.

I still think that Chad is too high on the list, however

Cheers. Yeh, trust a Crows fan to say that Very Happy

. I tried to be unbiased but I really rate Chad

Panthers wrote:

Great list Shooter!

Cornes higher then Brown!?

J.Brown should be in the top ten in my opinion.

Thanks Panthers. I think Jonathan Brown is over-rated, and I think Chad is a much better player. Brown has had one good season in his career.

Sibs#12 wrote:

Good list, but where is Kenelly?

Couldn't fit him in. All 50 players on the list are better in my opinion.

carlton09 wrote:

Hodge a bit high

JUDDY!!

Trav Cloke in there. hmm

Hodge is a gun, he deserves to be their.

Hmm I thought I might have been harsh on Cloke, but maybe I was too kind lol.

Thanks for your opinions guys, like I said this is just what I think and it doesn't mean I am right, your opinions are just as good as mine.

Guru Posts: 4881 Location: Melbourne

carlton09 wrote:

would you guys rather have Waite or Trav Cloke?

i think Waite better

Trav Cloke NO contest

Legend Posts: 12353 Age: 16 Location: Victoria

SMASH wrote:

carlton09 wrote:

would you guys rather have Waite or Trav Cloke?

i think Waite better

Trav Cloke NO contest

okay.

I dont really rate Travis Cloke. I think he is hopeless

Guest

Wait so i've started supporting a team without a single player in the Top 35 in the league??

Hmm....

Guru Posts: 6117 Age: 21

SBW wrote:

Wait so i've started supporting a team without a single player in the Top 35 in the league??

Hmm....

That's what makes Collingwood as good as they are.
They have no "superstars" just a lot of consistent performers.

Guru Posts: 4576 Age: 105

good list id rate Kerr in the top 10, thats just me though i think he's the most damaging player in the league.

and its a disgrace that Richard Tambling didnt even make the list let alone top 3, who do you think you are!

Guest

Shooter wrote:

SBW wrote:

Wait so i've started supporting a team without a single player in the Top 35 in the league??

Hmm....

That's what makes Collingwood as good as they are.
They have no "superstars" just a lot of consistent performers.

Ok i'll take your word for it Smile

Legend Posts: 11984 Age: 17

Scruffy wrote:

Good list.

Only things I dissagree with.

Goodes to high. >> 15th for me.
Cornes to high. >> 20th for me.
Bartel to low. >> Around 3ish for me.
Deledio to low. >> 45th for me.

Goodes is a great player but his injuries and sometimes inconsistent performances are what holds him back.

Guru Posts: 6117 Age: 21

Sibs#12 wrote:

Scruffy wrote:

Good list.

Only things I dissagree with.

Goodes to high. >> 15th for me.
Cornes to high. >> 20th for me.
Bartel to low. >> Around 3ish for me.
Deledio to low. >> 45th for me.

Goodes is a great player but his injuries and sometimes inconsistent performances are what holds him back.

He's a dual Brownlow medalist
How many of them are going around.

Goodes = Legend.