Best and Worst Recycled Players From Your Club

This thread is about the Best and Worst Recycled Players from your Club.

By recycled I mean played for a previous club if someone didn't know that Smile

You can have all-time players but have it under a different heading than Current Players.

For me:

CURRENT

Best: Daniel Motlop, David Rodan, Jason Davenport, Danny Meyer, Tom Logan

Worst: Have none at the moment Smile

ALL-TIME

Best: Gavin Wanganeen, Matthew Primus, Darryl Wakelin, Jarrad Schofield, Brett Montgomery, Byron Pickett, Damien Hardwick

Worst: Stuart Cochrane, Nathan Lonie, Aaron Shattock, Ian Downsborough

Guru Posts: 7555 Age: 21 Location: A land down under

Current - Best: Chris Judd
Worst: Jordan Bannister

ALl time- BEST: Chris Judd
Worst : Cain Ackland

Legend Posts: 10598 Age: 24

Current
Best: Daniel Pratt (but since he was first drafted by us, then drafted by Brisbane, then drafted by us again, does he count?)
Worst: Sam Power

All-time
Best: Shannon Grant
Worst: Jonathan Hay

Legend Posts: 11569 Age: 20 Location: Adelaide

CURRENT:

Best: Andrew McLeod, Brad Symes, Brad Moran
Worst: Nick Gill

ALL-TIME:

Best: Andrew McLeod, Darren Jarman
Worst: Wayne Carey

Legend Posts: 10598 Age: 24

Brad Moran?...

What's he done?

Legend Posts: 11569 Age: 20 Location: Adelaide

Cynic wrote:

Brad Moran?...

What's he done?

He's the best ruckman we've got atm, in my opinion. He's shown some good promise (last year vs. Carlton he kicked 4 goals, and was arguably among the best-on-ground), I'd expect him to be No. 1 ruckman in a couple of years

Cynic wrote:

Current
Best: Daniel Pratt (but since he was first drafted by us, then drafted by Brisbane, then drafted by us again, does he count?)
Worst: Sam Power

All-time
Best: Shannon Grant
Worst: Jonathan Hay

Yeah He Counts.

suggestion: Jade Rawlings for Worst of All-Time?

Guru Posts: 6118 Age: 901 Location: The Emirates

CBF doing all time

Current Best: Ray, King, Gram, Gardiner, Schneider, Dawson
Worst: None really

we are mad recyclers

Legend Posts: 10598 Age: 24

Teal Devils wrote:

Cynic wrote:

Current
Best: Daniel Pratt (but since he was first drafted by us, then drafted by Brisbane, then drafted by us again, does he count?)
Worst: Sam Power

All-time
Best: Shannon Grant
Worst: Jonathan Hay

Yeah He Counts.

suggestion: Jade Rawlings for Worst of All-Time?

Rawlings at least played a game.

Guru Posts: 2408 Age: 17 Location: Cooking up a Rioli

Best - Medders, L Brown (has filled a hole for us),

Worst - Corrie (just needs to get in the side and perform better when he is)

Guru Posts: 4576 Age: 105

Best for the tiges would be couso atm, Mortons done well too and Nathan Brown would have won the Charlie if he didnt snap his leg.

Worst: Hislop and Adam Thomson havent done much at all

Veteran Posts: 723 Age: 22 Location: Perth

At the moment:

Best: B.Guerra, S.Gilham, S.Dew, T.Croad

Worst: Not too sure at the moment

Guru Posts: 4860 Age: 18

at the moment: tyson stenglien
previous: stevie armstrong

Professional Posts: 238 Location: Newcastle

Teal Devils wrote:

This thread is about the Best and Worst Recycled Players from your Club.

By recycled I mean played for a previous club if someone didn't know that Smile

You can have all-time players but have it under a different heading than Current Players.

For me:

CURRENT

Best: Daniel Motlop, David Rodan, Jason Davenport, Danny Meyer, Tom Logan

Worst: Have none at the moment Smile

ALL-TIME

Best: Gavin Wanganeen, Matthew Primus, Darryl Wakelin, Jarrad Schofield, Brett Montgomery, Byron Pickett, Damien Hardwick

Worst: Stuart Cochrane, Nathan Lonie, Aaron Shattock, Ian Downsborough

What's Pav doing in a Power shirt. It's wack. Wink

Legend Posts: 11569 Age: 20 Location: Adelaide

TheFeldster wrote:

CURRENT:

Best: Andrew McLeod, Brad Symes, Brad Moran
Worst: Nick Gill

ALL-TIME:

Best: Andrew McLeod, Darren Jarman
Worst: Wayne Carey

I forgot Scott Thompson and Scott Stevens! How could I, they are good recycled players as well Smile

Professional Posts: 134 Age: 21 Location: Perth

only player i know we have that has been traded would be stenglien and kennedy,
prior to that we had chick, armstrong, and damian adkins, thats bout it

Veteran Posts: 678 Location: South Australia

BEST: C Bolton, Richards, Mattner, R Shaw, Jolly, Hall

WORST: the Luke Brennan pick up from Hawthorn last year wasn't too wise, and the Spida move wasn't at all successful

Guru Posts: 4860 Age: 18

Who did darren jolly used to play for ?? ilovv him !

western bulldogs fans would say that one of the worst recycled players would be andrew mcdougal from eagles he played like 2 games